Kes Movie Analysis Essay

Kes, the second feature directed by Ken Loach, is a remarkable film which manages the tricky balance between portraying the grim reality of the characters’ lives and holding out the possibility of hope for something better. The recent Criterion re-release, with a restored digital transfer of the film as well as a generous package of extras, offers the perfect opportunity to catch up with this outstanding work if you haven’t yet seen it and to revisit it, if you have.

Kes was adopted from the novel A Kestrel for a Knave by Barry Hines who co-wrote the screenplay with Loach and producer Tony Garnett. The title is a quotation from the 15th century Boke of St. Albans which pairs appropriate birds with social ranks from “An Eagle for an Emperor, a Gyrfalcon for a King…” to “a Kestrel for a Knave” meaning that the kestrel is the bird appropriate to the common man or in this case to the common boy.

The central character in Kes is Billy Casper (David Bradley, a schoolboy making his first appearance in film), a skinny 15-year-old about to leave school without having found any particular direction in life. An indifferent student largely ignored by his preoccupied mother (Lynne Perrie, in her first major screen role) and bullied by his classmates and older brother Jud (Freddie Fletcher, also in his first role), initially there’s nothing to suggest that Billy will be anything other than just another laborer in the coal mine or unskilled worker on the factory floor.

Yet something about the beauty of a falcon in flight captures Billy’s imagination and when he discovers a nest of kestrels on a nearby farm he decides to train one. Aided by a book on falconry stolen from a local shop, Billy becomes absorbed in training Kes, as he names his bird, and in the process finds focus for the first time in his life. When a sympathetic English teacher notices this transformation and invites him to deliver a talk to the class, Billy responds with an inspired lecture on falconry.

However, Billy Casper is not Billy Elliot nor is Kes an inspirational Disney movie about the triumph of the human spirit. Instead, Loach stays true to the reality of his characters and their world and a phrase attributed to Truman Capote might well be applied to Billy Casper and his kestrel, as well: The world is not kind to little things.

Kes is not entirely a grim slog, however, and Loach finds beauty within Billy’s world, most obviously in the scenes when he is training Kes. The film also includes a comic interlude involving a gym teacher (Brian Glover, in real life a schoolteacher and part-time professional wrestler) who fancies himself a footballer and tries to turn a cold, wet afternoon match between two teams of unenthusiastic boys into a Premier League showdown.

The Criterion edition of Kes is a two-disc set including a 24-page booklet with an essay by Graham Fuller. The film is presented with the choice of either the original soundtrack or the internationally-released post-synch soundtrack (intended to be easier to understand for those unfamiliar with the Yorkshire dialect spoken by the characters) and also has English subtitles. The second disc includes a making-of documentary (45 min.), a 1993 episode of The South Bank Show (49 min.) focused on Loach and his career, and the 1966 television film, Cathy Come Home (77 min.) directed by Loach for the BBC.

Although there is some overlap among these features, together they provide an excellent introduction to Loach and his work. The making-of documentary features interviews with Loach, producer Tony Garnett, cinematographer Chris Menges, and actor David Bradley. In it, Loach expresses his dissatisfaction with the “angry young men” films of the early '60s (e.g., This Sporting Life) which he felt did not get to the heart of the working-class experience and explains how his characteristic working methods (use of nonprofessional actors, preference for long shots) help produce films which, he believes, grant his characters the same respect that their real-life equivalents deserve.

The South Bank Show episode features clips from Loach’s film and television work as well as interviews with Loach, Garnett and others. It underlines Loach’s persistent concerns with (in his words) “young people being wasted” through lack of opportunity as well as his documentary-like approach to feature films and television.

Cathy Come Home was produced for the BBC anthology series The Wednesday Play which was intended to draw attention to different social problems in Britain. In Cathy Come Home the problem is the shortage of affordable housing, highlighted by the fictional story of a young couple (played by Carol White and Ray Brooks) and their three children who suffer a series of misfortunes after the husband loses his job and they are evicted from their apartment. From this point their lives spiral downwards, a trajectory mirrored by their increasingly unsatisfactory living conditions as they move from their apartment to a caravan (trailer) park to a squat and finally to a public shelter.

Shot largely with hand-held camera and in real locations Cathy Come Home offers a polyphony of voices commenting on the characters and their situation and, although overly melodramatic and on the nose for modern tastes, is interesting as an early expression of Loach’s concerns. An 11-minute afterword by Graham Fuller places this program in context and describes Loach’s influence on British television.

Kes is a classic British film whose appeal has not diminished over the years. Even if you’ve seen this film before, the quality of the restoration and the extras provided with the Criterion edition make it worth revisiting.


Director: Ken Loach
Cast: David Bradley, Freddie Fletcher, Colin Welland
Distributor: Criterion
Studio: United Artists
Release Date: 2011-04-19

Kes (1969 United Kingdom 113 mins)

Source: Chapel Films Prod Co: Kestrel Films/Woodfall Films Prod: Tony Garnett Dir: Ken Loach Scr: Ken Loach, Barry Hines and Tony Garnett, based on the novel A Kestrel for a Knave by Barry Hines Phot: Chris Menges Ed: Roy Watts Art Dir: William McCrow Mus: John Cameron

Cast: David Bradley, Lynne Perrie, Freddie Fletcher, Colin Welland, Brian Glover, Bob Bowes

Ranked seventh in the BFI 100’s recent selection of the favourite British films of the 20th century, Kes remains Ken Loach’s masterpiece (1). While the director has reached similar aesthetic heights in subsequent years (Days of Hope [1975] and Raining Stones [1993] immediately spring to mind), the film remains a template for Loach’s abiding concerns: the struggle of the British working class to achieve life’s basic needs, dramatised through the plight of an individual character; the significant impact of public institutions upon personal lives; sensitive performances with an ear for regional dialects; and an unobtrusive yet evocative visual style that illuminates character and place in a naturalistic fashion. Arriving as the ’60s drew to a close, Kes heralds the end of “kitchen sink realism” and the true arrival of one of contemporary cinema’s major artists.

Loach began his directorial career at the BBC in 1963 where he met story-editor turned producer Tony Garnett (2). Committed socialists, the pair collaborated on a series of stylistically ambitious films that addressed Britain’s social problems, including homelessness, teenage delinquency, union politics and abortion (3). Their success led to Poor Cow (1968), a flawed commercial production that wears its Godardian and Brechtian influences too readily on its sleeve (4). Frustrated by the BBC and Hollywood bureaucracies, Loach and Garnett created their own production company in order to make Kes. They shot the film on location in eight weeks for just £157,000 (5).

Kes details the life of Billy Casper (David Bradley), a lonely teen facing a bleak future in a Yorkshire mining town. An outcast at school, Billy’s slight frame and unkempt appearance make him an easy target for teachers and bullies alike. Unfortunately, home provides no respite. Billy’s father is absent, his inattentive mother (Lynne Perrie) offers little guidance or love (referring to Billy as “a hopeless case”), and his abusive older brother Jud (Freddie Fletcher) takes out his hostility through punches and insults. However, hope appears in the form of a kestrel, which Billy captures as a fledgling and trains to fly on command. Soon, the bird reveals not only Billy’s untapped potential, but also his desire to escape his toxic environment. It’s no accident, of course, that Billy is obsessed with the only bird owned by the lowest social orders during medieval times. As Loach notes, “It’s a bird for the riff-raff of the world.” (6)

Faithfully adapted from the Barry Hines novel A Kestrel for a Knave, Kes carefully exposes the links between economic opportunity, social services, and personal fulfillment. Public institutions, in Loach’s view, carry an obligation to provide proper employment and housing to its people – without a job or home, one cannot feel safe or secure, much less happy. While public education aims to inspire children and equip them with the intellectual tools necessary for adulthood, Billy’s school repeatedly fails him. Headmaster Gryce (Bob Bowes) canes Billy and several other boys “knowing fully well that you’ll be back for it time and time and time again.” Billy’s buffoonish P.E. instructor (Brian Glover) humiliates the boy for lacking a gym uniform, and then forces him to withstand an ice-cold shower. Most appallingly, a youth employment officer (Bernard Atha) casually identifies Billy as best suited for “manual labor” and suggests trade school or a future as a miner. Billy emphatically protests, “I’m not going down in the pit”, recognizing the horrible hand already dealt to his older brother.

Jud’s dreary and dangerous job, in fact, inspires the hostility toward Billy and his mother. A lengthy sequence depicts Jud’s walk to work and the elaborate, claustrophobic journey he and his colleagues must make daily into the pit. Before going down, another miner notices Jud’s poor mood and explains, “Should be on top of the world on a day like today.” Jud replies, “In about ten minutes, we’ll be on the bottom of it.” To Loach’s great credit, the sequence humanises Jud, while also providing a portentous view of things-to-come for Billy. As Jacob Leigh points out, “Kes protests against an educational system which fails to recognize individual talent, and it suggests that this is a consequence of a capitalist society which demands a steady supply of unskilled manual labour.” (7) Jud’s dismal situation illustrates the vital importance of opportunity to a young person and much of Kes‘ narrative drive rests on the question of whether Billy will be similarly wasted.

The film’s centerpiece offers a degree of hope. Encouraged by Mr. Farthing (Colin Welland), the school’s lone compassionate teacher, Billy describes to his class how he captured and trained the kestrel. Displaying an unexpected enthusiasm, he slowly opens up and offers great detail about flying the bird off-leash for the first time. It’s the type of sequence in which Loach demonstrates his prodigious directorial skills. Billy’s story begins in long shot with the boy slumped against his desk in the lower part of the frame. As Billy gains authority and presence throughout the tale, Loach cuts back and forth between the boy, Mr. Farthing, and the interested class. Each time Loach returns to Billy, he is framed tighter and the sequence ends with Billy in one of the film’s few close-ups. Without being diagrammatic, the boy’s rising enthusiasm compels Loach to move the camera progressively closer in a beautiful integration of form and content.

Stylistically, Kes represents a significant development from Loach’s earlier work. Eschewing the handheld camera, jump cuts, and abrupt sound cues characteristic of the BBC films, Loach and cinematographer Chris Menges adopt a natural, yet controlled visual style. Shots appear aesthetically pleasing without becoming pictorial. The film’s muted color palette presents a world distanced just far enough from reality to resonate.

With the exception of Colin Welland, the entire cast features non-professionals discovered in Barnsley, including the remarkable David Bradley (8). Like Loach’s subsequent films, Kes preserves the accents and colloquialisms of northern England in the film’s dialogue, adding an authenticity absent from most commercial British productions. Bradley’s alternately emotional and reserved performance surely ranks as one of the great adolescent portraits in cinema, joining the likes of Jean-Pierre Leaud in The 400 Blows (François Truffaut, 1959). As Loach says, “In fact, David Bradley… proved the film’s central thesis by his performance; namely, there’s a lot of ability that nobody knows about and that just gets written off.” (9)

Despite truly bleak moments and an ambiguous finale, Loach infuses the film with enough warmth and humor to carry its audience along. Like Antoine Doinel, Billy has a penchant for daydreaming, insubordination, and petty theft (he steals a book on falconry after a public library refuses to lend him one) which contributes to his plight, if only in minor ways. When he steals a pint of milk and then stops to joke with the milkman, he displays a swagger recognisable in teens everywhere. Loach’s attention to detail consistently reveals aspects of daily life rarely featured on film. For example, few who see Kes ever forget Mr. Sugden’s introduction on the football field. Practicing various head butts to the tune of BBC’s Sports Night theme, the P.E. teacher humorously represents every awful failed athlete-turned-educator.

An unexpected success on its initial release (the film made its money back in the UK alone), Kes continues to resonate with contemporary audiences. On a 1999 return visit to Barnsley, six different fans stopped David Bradley in one day about the film (10). Critics rightly heralded its 30th anniversary re-release as a major event. Most significantly, Kes introduced Loach to the international film scene, a platform from which he has consistently challenged and provoked audiences ever since.


  1. In 1999, the British Film Institute polled 1000 U.K. critics and film industry professionals to compile their list. The results appear on the BFI’s web-site at Loach’s My Name is Joe (1998) also ranks in at number 91.
  2. Leonard Quart, “A Fidelity to the Real: An Interview with Ken Loach and Tony Garnett”, Cineaste, Fall 1980, pp 26–29.
  3. Up the Junction (1965) and Cathy Come Home (1966) are the two most famous examples. For an introduction to Loach and Garnett’s BBC productions, see Loach on Loach, ed. Graham Fuller, Faber and Faber, London, 1998, pp 1–31.
  4. Steven Soderbergh used extracts from Poor Cow to depict Terence Stamp’s past in The Limey (1999).
  5. Alexander Walker, Hollywood UK: The British Film Industry in the Sixties, Stein & Day, New York, 1974, p. 378.
  6. Fuller, p. 43.
  7. Jacob Leigh, The Cinema of Ken Loach: Art in the Service of the People, Wallflower Press, London, 2002, p. 64.
  8. Welland won the 1970 Best Supporting Actor award from the British Film Academy for his beautifully realised performance. He later earned an Oscar for his screenplay for Chariots of Fire (Hugh Hudson, 1981).
  9. Julian Petley, “Ken Loach – Politics, Protest and the Past”, Monthly Film Bulletin, March 1987, p. 94.
  10. Anon., “Role of a Lifetime,” Guardian, September 28, 1999.,4273,3906577,00.html

One thought on “Kes Movie Analysis Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *